HOURS: M-F 10am to 6pm, Sat 9am to 5pm, Sun 9am to 2pm
HOURS: M-F 10am to 6pm, Sat 9am to 5pm, Sun 9am to 2pm

Unicorns & Mermaids Cakes and Cupcakes

Beautifully decorated cakes and cupcakes for your themed birthday party and special occasion celebration. Our most popular chiffon based "Dream Cake" is a heavenly choice for any party. Or choose from a variety of our delicious buttercream and whipped cream cakes or fun cupcakes. We make it easy with personalized custom photo cakes ready for next day pick up. Simply add your custom message to our unicorn and mermaid cake themes! Trust your custom cake to the oldest bakery in Santa Cruz. Family owned and operated since 1975. Providing the community with the best cake and service for generations!
  • Iridescent Unicorn Rings (free design)
    Iridescent Unicorn Rings (free design)
    $31.95 - $239.95
    Pick Up By Tomorrow /5 days / 7 Days
    Receive By 5 Days / 7 Days Rush Available
  • Mermaid Tail Wrap Rings (free design)
    Mermaid Tail Wrap Rings (free design)
    $31.95 - $239.95
    Pick Up By Tomorrow /5 days / 7 Days
    Receive By 5 Days / 7 Days Rush Available
  • Mermaids are Magical Custom Photo Cake
    Mermaids are Magical Custom Photo Cake
    $51.95 - $219.95
    Pick Up By Tomorrow /5 days / 7 Days
    Receive By 5 Days / 7 Days Rush Available
  • Mermaids are Magical Photo Cake
    Mermaids are Magical Photo Cake
    $46.95 - $214.95
    Pick Up By Tomorrow /5 days / 7 Days
    Receive By 5 Days / 7 Days Rush Available
  • Mystic Mermaid Toy Set with Photo Layer Cake
    Birthday sheet cake with photo layer of mermaid and toy tail and underwater creatures.
    $69.95 - $219.95
    Pick Up By Tomorrow /5 days / 7 Days
    Receive By 5 Days / 7 Days Rush Available
  • Princess Shield Custom Photo Cake
    Princess Shield Custom Photo Cake
    $51.95 - $219.95
    Pick Up By Tomorrow /5 days / 7 Days
    Receive By 5 Days / 7 Days Rush Available
  • Princess Unicorn Custom Photo Cake
    Princess Unicorn Custom Photo Cake
    $51.95 - $219.95
    Pick Up By Tomorrow /5 days / 7 Days
    Receive By 5 Days / 7 Days Rush Available
  • Princess Unicorn Photo Cake
    Princess Unicorn Photo Cake
    $46.95 - $214.95
    Pick Up By Tomorrow /5 days / 7 Days
    Receive By 5 Days / 7 Days Rush Available
  • Rainbow Unicorn Rings (free design)
    Rainbow Unicorn Rings (free design)
    $31.95 - $239.95
    Pick Up By Tomorrow /5 days / 7 Days
    Receive By 5 Days / 7 Days Rush Available
  • Sparkle like a Unicorn Photo Cake
    Sparkle like a Unicorn Photo Cake
    $46.95 - $214.95
    Pick Up By Tomorrow /5 days / 7 Days
    Receive By 5 Days / 7 Days Rush Available
  • Swirlettes and Bubbles Cake
    Birthday sheet cake with ocean and memaid themed swirls, corals, stars and underwater bubbles.
    $41.95 - $214.95
    Pick Up By Tomorrow /5 days / 7 Days
    Receive By 5 Days / 7 Days Rush Available
  • Swirlettes and Sea Pearls Cake
    Birthday sheet cake with ocean and mermaid themed swirls, corals and pearls.
    $41.95 - $214.95
    Pick Up By Tomorrow /5 days / 7 Days
    Receive By 5 Days / 7 Days Rush Available
  • Unicorn and Hearts Cake
    Birthday sheet cake with buttercream piped unicorn with colorful mane and horn and hearts.
    $69.95 - $234.95
    Pick Up By Tomorrow /5 days / 7 Days
    Receive By 5 Days / 7 Days Rush Available
  • Unicorn Creation with Photo Layer and Rainbow Cake
    Birthday sheet cake with unicorn toy set on photo layer with sprayed rainbow and unicorn rings.
    $69.95 - $219.95
    Pick Up By Tomorrow /5 days / 7 Days
    Receive By 5 Days / 7 Days Rush Available